Bethel Church in Redding, CA, is a congregation rooted in the love of God and dedicated to worldwide transformation through revival. It’s our goal for God’s love to be manifest in signs, wonders, and miracles. The atmosphere at Bethel is charged with faith and exuberant joy, which manifests in all we do. We believe we’re on the edge of the greatest revival of all time. It’s our vision to see history become His-story as the kingdom of this world becomes the kingdom of our God. We welcome you to join us in this adventure!
denominations tend to
want to clean up the record of the moves
of god that they’ve experienced the
shantung revival in china is a great
example
there is a book out on the shenandoah
bible that will bore you to tears
because it tells you about all the maybe
outcomes of this these this number this
church this missionary but not the
process and the process is where god
radically touched this family radically
touched this church this child
and and it brought about incredible
fruit for his name
[Music]
this idea how do you know it’s the holy
spirit versus another spirit a demonic
spirit some uh the internet again has
created uh something i’ve never heard of
the the or hadn’t really heard of the
kundalini spirit and somehow that that’s
in operation here
um
again i
i never heard of it until i was actually
i didn’t even so that’s another another
deal like that again you could the the
critic could say well you can’t just
because you’re ignorant doesn’t mean
it’s not true whatever else but the the
basic idea is a fallacy because it looks
like something else it is something else
and so again we’re talking about the
fruit of our life and then this idea
that we’re actually in relationship with
this divine being the with the lord i’m
talking about yahweh the covenant god of
the old testament we’re in relationship
with him so we are not afraid and we
know his voice my sheep know my voice so
yeah i i know like this is this spirit
of love and truth and integrity this
this being whom i’m experiencing his
presence at the moment this is holiness
this is perfect goodness there’s no
there’s no i don’t wonder allow like
might this be a demon
in those moments never uh it doesn’t
cross my mind because of the integrity
of the experience exactly that’s
happening so exactly
i think we’re supposed to learn to
recognize the presence of the holy
spirit just in our own personal life not
just in a ministry context but just in
life
because when i learn to recognize his
presence it’s much easier for me to
discern
the authenticity of maybe somebody’s
testimony yeah maybe
the decision they’re about to make
maybe the manifestation of them
physically
you can you start to recognize him when
he’s doing something and it’s a lot
easier i was in a situation way back at
the beginning where i was surrounded by
what appeared to be chaos just because
of the numbers of people
i closed my eyes so that i could cancel
out what i was seeing
and i and i became overwhelmingly
overwhelmingly aware
it’s the same presence of the holy
spirit that i experienced in my in my
worship time with the lord
and
as long as i
wasn’t offended in my mind
by what i didn’t understand
i was anchored if you will i was i was
anchored in recognizing
this is god
and then i was able to
to then begin to respond
more
positively appropriately towards what
was happening around me yeah and this is
just a portion of our walk with jesus
this isn’t in every meeting it’s not in
every devotional time it’s not in every
uh you know session of school by any
stretch of imagination we have folks who
have profound physical experiences and
then don’t for a long time um or
you talk about turning aside there are
times when i i won’t have any but i’ll
get into a prayer ministry time when
suddenly i can experience this presence
physically
and emotionally in like a deeper more
dear way than kind of in my own quiet
time you know alone
um
and then i think they’re part of how do
you know it’s not the enemy we do ask
that like when we’re pastoring
environments so you’ve got to know how
to pass through the environment but i’ll
see some manifestations where i’ve kind
of walked up to people introduced myself
told them my role so that i have
authority and you know they’re not and
i’m not we’re not afraid of wrecking
what god’s doing when the lord’s in it
you’re not going to wreck it because i’m
not coming as a mocker or you know to an
accuser i’d be like hi i’m dan one of
the pastors here this looks very intense
what you’re experiencing
is this the lord
you know and then they sometimes they
can they have told me they’ve just
nodded yes you know and um because they
can’t speak it’s so intense experience
like exactly and like so you’re
physically fine you’re not having a
stroke or anything and you know be like
yeah they’ll nod yes and i’m like okay
at other times i’ll talk with them and
say hey you know are you doing all right
are you scared and they’ll nod yes
you’re like do you feel is this the lord
or the demonic so we’re actually
pastoring in that moment that’s huge um
and again i don’t have to do it all the
time because all of our meetings are not
nearly anything like this but you do
have to have leadership in the
environment and some conversations
happen in the moment uh there and then
some happen afterwards like hey your
response to the lord’s presence is i
know it’s meaningful to you it’s
incredibly distracting to the rest of us
so we’re going to need you to
to to dial in to cooperate with the holy
spirit in a way that actually doesn’t
distract from the meeting
you know at this time or that isn’t
drawing so much attention even though
your heart might not be to draw
attention that is what’s happening so
exactly it’s um in our in our culture
we’re not afraid to confront those sorts
of things as we need to we’ll let them
go a little long like we’ll just let
them go a little longer i remember one
time we were in a um we’re in a uh a
joy-filled meeting and um a woman was on
her knees she came to the middle of the
altar sorry the middle of the aisle the
center altar and she is on her knees
crying out it’s the blood it’s the blood
it’s the blood and worship’s going it’s
loud there’s joyous praise everywhere
but i remember that moment thinking the
it wasn’t an act of praise that she was
involved in in that moment but i’m like
lord this could be you like she could be
the lone person we could all be in a
mode like it’s time to experience joy
let’s do our thing
and she could have been the lone person
actually like i’m this the lord’s i’m
interested in you prepondering my
sacrifice tonight i’m interested in you
pondering the sacredness of myself
giving love so i’m listening and trying
to like how do you do it i don’t know
how to describe what i’m doing am i
trying to do more than my mind and more
than my taste more than my preference
and more than my emotions excellent and
try to listen like lord is this you are
you on this young woman taking us in a
direction
so i just let her go on for a while now
other people were noticing but they saw
me like 10 feet behind her and they’re
like okay good leader a leader is paying
attention and um so then she i come up
and i say you know at the end my
discernment was like this isn’t what the
lord’s doing tonight and so i kind of
just sat down and introduced myself we
had a great conversation about what you
know what the lord was doing with her
and i kind of gently said it i love what
the lord’s doing um it it doesn’t seem
to be quite what’s corporately happening
so you know if you’d like to kind of
continue in this maybe uh just in a less
obvious place or less
quiet in a more quiet way yeah i’d love
to facilitate that or or it might be
that your assignment’s been done and and
it’s time to join the lord and praising
for his glorious sacrifice you know so
just like letting her process that’s
beautiful what she was up to in that
moment that’s beautiful and um and and
not getting uh not getting
kind of locked up and what are people
going to think and yeah and this is
exactly what the group’s doing and i i
just recommend that sort of benny has a
fun story i don’t know if you remember
where there was a
i’m going to take the time to tell the
story so as a young woman dancing in the
front in a somewhat provocative fashion
close to you during worship
yeah that was actually that was actually
my story oh yeah she was dancing in
front of me in a very strange way yeah
and i it got cold around me physically
cold and i
so i walked about 10 feet away
to see uh if the if the room was just
cold i got about 10 feet away and it was
normal
i got back close to her i remembered an
experience that my brother had in a
horrible spiritual time with his
ministry in san francisco and stuff
and it reminded me of his description of
that encounter yeah and so i went over
to summer who is our dancer
and i said summer i need you to dance
before the lord we need to break
something and then i turned to my wife
and i said honey i
i need you to pray for her and uh and
literally the moment summer began to
dance before the lord this gal collapsed
right in front of me and it was it was a
horrible demonic thing
very s subtle but horrible she collapsed
in front of me
benny my wife leaned forward and began
to pray for her just brought her through
great deliverance into salvation and it
ended up being a very amazing thing but
it started by
not just visually uh what she was doing
it started because of a temperature
change interesting and then it reminds
me of hebrews 5 have your senses trained
to discern good and evil that there was
actually something triggered
that seemed to be more biblical than my
experience was
historically yeah that that had never
happened before well and then the folks
who were that were part of that story
from the outside they were just offended
at what she was doing and that she was
so you know
sure so so much in your environment and
doing that so there’s a moment where we
didn’t act in utter response to that
offense but act actually acted in hey
let’s let’s uh move with spiritual
authority yeah in this area and with
kindness in this order yeah there’s a
redemptive solution
yeah no that’s that’s that’s the truth
absolutely
so to be clear not everybody has to
manifest and not every denomination not
every church has to have these
manifestations going on that’s not what
we’re saying to be truly spiritual or
truly connected to god or truly
represent you’ve got to do it like us
that’s
no no it’s just hunger for god let him
do what he does you know so we would say
everybody should be hungry i hope so
absolutely yeah absolutely
yeah you can’t have god offer something
that extreme that extravagant that
extraordinary and sit and do nothing you
know he welcomes us to come and to seek
him
he’s already here yes but to seek him
more diligently to set our face towards
him and to seek him more diligently it’s
a great privilege of life yeah so
cultivating the hunger and then
responding to his presence in the way
that he comes just with as much
authenticity as you can bring to that
yeah so the great revivals of the church
oftentimes had these manifestations of
various kinds and we don’t we don’t
quite talk about them a lot we talk
about their fervent prayer but you can
go back into the record if it hasn’t
been sanitized or you know they haven’t
kind of changed the stories a little bit
and the old revivals
full of unusual
signs and wonders manifestations of the
lord’s presence on the meeting on the
movement you’re good yeah
the
denominations tend to
want to clean up the record of the moves
of god that they’ve experienced the
shantung revival in china is a great
example
there is a book out on the chanting
revival that will bore you to tears
because it tells you about all the
maybe outcomes of this these this number
this church this missionary but not the
process and the process is where god
radically touched this family radically
touched this church this child
and and it brought about incredible
fruit for his name
and uh and so there are two versions of
that book randy clark our dear friend uh
republished the book uh in the original
content so you could see what actually
happened and this is it’s dialogue
between missionaries of what’s happening
in their part of the world and uh it’s
extraordinary to see the the the mighty
outpouring wow the holy spirit the cain
ridge revival went on for many many
years and it was very unusual
but uh but it was it was so powerful so
legitimate and oftentimes what happens
is these great moves of god
they have a a an offensive element to it
that’s that always seems to be the case
the lord does not mind offending his
spirit no he doesn’t
uh
one one of our
friends from years ago said uh he will
offend your mind to reveal your heart
and that happens so much but these these
great moves of god they will actually
so position society and culture to
advance in the years following the
revival that really really is quite
extraordinary
real transformation takes place so
it’s a glorious thing but uh
but it doesn’t do any of us favors to
whitewash history to to
until it looks like what we want it to
look yes it’s just not honest no
beautify
that’s been part of the journey i
mentioned like discovering that
spiritual discernment wasn’t just
my taste or past experience
those really feel very similar inside
what i my taste what i prefer and my
past experience does like it’s i discern
brother that’s the devil so i have to be
really cautious
well
and it’s an arrogant position it’s like
well ouch build it yeah
where you look at something and you go
well that can’t be god and basically the
judge is he didn’t do it to me first so
why would he do it to you yeah yeah
absolutely it’s just a poor standard of
judging things yeah so look look back in
past revivals find the find the first
sources if you can and not the later
ones where each other they they were
sanitized and by sometimes we we took
out the spooky stuff the unusual
stuff that isn’t quite in the scripture
but not forbidden from scripture you
know and but unusual experiences
and almost always in every greek
movement of god there have been these
experiences which is true so what about
if you come from a church though that
doesn’t like you know there’s lots of
traditions i i was it came from a
non-charismatic church and
and um so i you know always wanted the
lord to do whatever he wanted but you
know i was just taught that this is what
church is like and this is what’s normal
and yet you know we were hungry for the
lord and we would have said we were
hungry for the lord some of us more
hungry than others you know at some
point sure but do you have a sense of
like why some churches move uh have
experiences of these manifestations and
other places don’t
i don’t know i think the risk element is
a part of it so if you don’t like risk
you probably won’t
yeah
usually i mean the lord can cross the
line and
and touch you anywhere you want
something it’s all through scripture you
know
um but typically typically our hunger
precedes a great outpouring not always
not always but typically hunger or
hunger for more just that realization
there’s so much more to walking with
jesus than what i know yeah and i’m just
hungry and there are
a whole school that would throw up
alarms at that point and say you have to
be careful for deception but jesus made
that pretty clear he said you know
he’s not going to give you a stone
instead of bread he’s not going to give
you a scorpion instead of a fish he’s
not going to
you’re not going to pursue him and then
have him trick you and allow you to get
into a a deceptive thing unless you’ve
got personal issues that you’re
unwilling to repent of then of course
there are other factors completely
outside community and can’t have can’t
have any interaction exactly you know
with them sometimes that’ll happen so
yeah the other um you know maybe why
doesn’t happen is sometimes we you know
you kind of get what you teach like we
we don’t we used to have more public um
uh public prophecy accompanied with
tongues because we would teach on it yes
we were smaller we had a microphone
up at the front forward right and people
would take the risk and they’d they’d
speak to us i feel like the lord’s
saying this and then they would jump up
but we don’t know now we have church
full of visitors we can’t quite take the
risk in our main meetings it doesn’t
make sense to we don’t know everybody
that’s in the room
um so we and we don’t teach into that so
when you don’t teach something you kind
of don’t get it yeah at some point so
that’d be part i would say part of what
happens
and my own experience too is i i as
being a you know kind of a not very
charismatic leader in a charismatic
church in the early 90s here i
i just found that my comfortable like
first of all i didn’t know what the
anointing was like the idea of the
anointing like
really didn’t have a grid for it it
wasn’t something we talked about
um we if we did it was purely emotional
like that you just that’s a code word
for your your an emotionless you know
your emotions
um but i remember like i was
uncomfortable leading my people in
anything i couldn’t sustain
so like if i get super hungry
i might not be super hungry in three
weeks
so like i’m not i don’t want to take you
to the edge and go i actually can’t
follow through with that so i i stuck
with my skills
with my gifts what i knew that i could
do for the lord’s glory like why venture
into some place that i’m not comfortable
yeah i i’m totally depend on the lord to
show up you know i can actually prepare
a pretty decent sermon even if he
doesn’t show up i’m not being critical
but i mean like you know it’s from the
bible it’s accurate everybody can go
amen but i i remember some of the the
signs and wonders and the manifestations
they were uncomfortable to me as a
leader again i’m not throwing a rock at
any leader i’m telling you my own story
is like i was like i don’t i can’t
sustain this
so i don’t know
i’m afraid to move into it and uh
aggressively so that might be something
that some of our our leaders are like i
don’t i’ve never been trained in this
and i’ll tell you going through bible
school and stuff i wasn’t trained in
this how to lead a meeting in faith
how to experience holy spirit and power
you know um you know how to prophesy
these were not these were not seminary
classes on how to prophesy
but you know when i first came i must
say see peter wagner i took a couple
classes from him and it’s fuller and i
you know i did yeah i did get some some
insight into that when i first came you
remember
certain things began to happen yeah
within a short period of time yeah i
know
and uh and alan ray one of our key guys
on staff came to me privately said you
know he said we want to help you pastor
this
but we’re learning at the same pace as
the people yeah
can we meet privately yeah and i thought
brilliant idea so i brought a team down
from weberville and hayfork and
and met in uh yeah in a home yeah and
then our teams just prayed for and all
all that happened was the presence of
god showed up the power of god showed up
in a very
wonderful way yeah
and it just put our lead or our staff
yeah you know two weeks ahead of
everyone else yeah and that’s all we
need yeah that’s what we do
it’s just that i was maybe like two days
after those meetings but yeah
but
that’s the point is it it gave us a
point of reference together where
literally we’re learning together you
have to you have to become a novice to
grow
uh you know jesus
he said i’m so glad you didn’t reveal
these things to the educator to the wise
the lord that you reveal it to babes and
sometimes you have to become childlike
to really get what god is saying what
he’s doing and that’s what happened to
all of us
as we were reduced
positively to being childlike